Monday, June 10, 2013

Book 2: Chains

* Disclaimer*

These are simply my opinions and you too are entitled to yours! So feel free to disagree and comment below, I also encourage you to read the novel so you can form an opinion.

Book: Chains by Laurie Halse Anderson
Before I read the novel impression:
(sigh) Well... at least its not sailing.
5/10 stars

After I read it:

I just couldn't do it. It was painful to read and I felt like, even though the book is only a bit over 200 pages it felt like ages. This is why I took so long to read it. I forced myself to read it in chunks but it just never got interesting to me. I was comparing this novel to Hang a Thousand Trees with Ribbons by Ann Rinaldi and it just couldn't compare. 

after reading: 2/ 10 stars


*From here on out there will be spoilers*

My Overall Summary:
The story revolves around the main antagonist Isabel who is accompanied by her sister Ruth. They were supposed to be freed after their master dies but unfortunately the master's son claims them as his due to the absence of the lawyer. He takes them and sells them to a terribly cruel couple, turning down a couple who knew their mother who has died. The couple is a pair of major players on the British side of the war. They dock in New York and pretend to be sympathizers with the American cause. They are taken to the couple's home after Isabel has a brief encounter with Curzon who says she will be freed if she can spy for the American cause. She brushed him off the first time she speaks to him but quickly finds out how cruel the couple is and reports findings about British bribery to some high ranking officers in the American cause. The second time she reports findings to high ranking officers it forces her master and his cronies to flee the city giving a chance for Mrs. Lockton (The wife of their master) to be even more cruel. She sends Ruth to Charleston and accuses Isabel of hurting her out of anger because of her sister and is found guilty before a jury. Thus, she is branded with an 'I' on her cheek for insubordination. The British come to New York and capture Curzon, in turn she continues to feed him food as he has become her friend. After a long period of waiting she helps break Curzon out of jail and flees the area to find her sister Ruth. In the process she steals a boat and rows until passing out and ending the book with her thinking that she is dead next to Curzon.

The good: 
The author has a good writing style that is simple and pleasant for a grade schooler to read. Many may really enjoy the character of Isabel who is a strong a determined character. There is a clear definition of good and bad and the historical actions line up very well with actual history. The story is a 'spy' story that many modern readers will find interesting if they do not enjoy historical novels. 

The bad:

I would like to point out the majority of the bad in this section is my opinion in the hopes that it will clarify what I had troubles with.

The plot was very stereotypical and predictable. From the moment I picked up this book I knew very well that the little girl would get a terrible master (I would like to point out I found Mrs. Lockton to be a very weak 'villan' as the normal life of a slave if the master was cruel, would often be much worse.) and that she would flee eventually, probably with a friend she makes. There was an EXTREMELY American bias in the story as the British are shown as nothing but terrible people. As a fan of history and particularly European history, this bias I found quite annoying. Many British were trying to keep it all together as the majority of the men were away from their homes for the first times in their lives. There is also the story itself, the author tried to juggle the whole spy thing, with friendship, and a strong American bias. I felt like the story had a sort of identity crisis, is it a story of friendship or war, is it more to encourage a lose of history or just create a bias in the young generation? My final complaint is that I really couldn't relate with the character. I know, I'm coming from the perspective of an 18 year old from Colorado in modern times but I mean I felt no sympathy for basically any character besides Curzon who had a clear cause. Isabel was the classic modern female character, strong and independent, which continues the modern trend of strong bias. A slave who was a slave from birth would be taught to hold their tongue and not disrespect the master- that made her unrealistic in such a strong sense it repulsed me. 

I guess the reason I had such a hard time with this book is just how modern it is, having been trained in advanced literature studies at my school... I guess it's the same reason I can't watch modern movies too! Ha ha. 

Favorite scene:

Probably when the author wrote the dream sequence when Isabel was drugged, I really enjoyed the detail she used. I'm a really big fan of detail.

Sorry this one was such a bummer, I have really strong opinions. I do enjoy childrens books I really do! I just need to get to the ones I like. 

On a side note, most of the books I actually liked as a kid have been removed:  Lily's Crossing, In the Year of the Boar and Jackie Robinson, Search for Delicious, and a few more I can't quite remember right now.

I will be seeing you soon with The Seven Wonders of Sassafras Springs.

No comments:

Post a Comment