* Disclaimer*
These are simply my opinions and you too are entitled to
yours! So feel free to disagree and comment below, I also encourage you to read
the novel so you can form an opinion.
Book: Room One: A Mystery or Two by Andrew Clements
Before I read the novel impression:
A mystery... really? And from Andrew Clements, he's a school story person, NOT a mystery writer. I am not looking forward to this.
4 / 10
After I read the novel impression:
Not bad, a touching story but there was no mystery! I really don't understand, what was the mystery? The house? The Girl? Those were all answered within the first 2 or 3 chapters. Cute story, it's just NOT a mystery.
6 / 10
* From here on out there will be spoilers*
My overall summary:
So this kid Ted who lives a happily mundane life delivering newspapers and going to school. He is quite content with the only adventure in his life being the mysteries he reads. One day he catches a glimpse of a girl in an abandoned house window. He begins to think about it constantly and decides to go to the house after school. He sits there and nothing is found, so like a good detective he comes back the next day. He still sees nothing but as he walks out of the house he is stopped by a girl who confronts him about what he was doing there and makes him promise to not tell anyone. He brings food the next day and finds the girls name is April and meets her brother and Mother. He continues to bring food but accidentally runs into his teacher which results in him telling her the secret with the family. Now the family is not a criminal family but one that lost their Dad in Iraq leaving the Mother paranoid about her family so they run. Their car breaks down and the family is forced to find shelter, and that shelter was the abandoned house. The next day after he tells his teacher the family is gone with no traces of where they went. After going to the house and looking for clues for days he finally notices that the suppies he bought them are gone with a note left from April saying their close by. He discovers their house and asks his mother if he could help them. She agrees and makes phone calls to people to prep for the work taking in a family would be. Soon the whole town knows and a festival ensues to welcome the family. He goes to pick up the family but they have already left due to the paranoia of the Mother. The town soon becomes known for its hospitality and welcomes any family with hard times. April calls Ted later on and leaves him a present, a copy of Sherlock Holmes.
Good:
The plot is unique, I was expecting a bit of a different story, more along the lines of a Haddix book but Clements kept his style and made a feel good book about community instead. The main character Ted was very likable and was a good role model as he was a boy scout and an all around good kid. The story was interesting after the initial hump in the story that involves the background of the main character and such. The work is well written with some twists most kids wouldn't see coming (I kind of already knew the Mom would make a run for it, but it was an interesting twist most kids wouldn't expect.) The majority of the aspect I liked in the novel was how strong of a role model Ted is. I also really enjoyed the descriptive language. :)
Bad:
Still is a mystery to me what is mystery was. (Haha) I guess it could be that he was trying to find out who the girl was and where she went after he had met her... but those a pretty weak mysteries. The novel need something, an extra oomph to make it great but it just came across as a rather mediocre book. It certainly wasn't terrible but the tempo could have been better paced. The beginning was killer to get over because it was just... bland, but after that is was fine. I guess I could say it just isn't one of Clements better books. I really can't pin it down to one thing, I guess you'll just have to read it yourself and see what I mean! :)
Favorite moment:
When the whole town gathered to welcome the family. My favorite moment ends there because it really bummed me out they left. I knew it was coming but still, I would have liked them to be welcomed. (Small town hospitality for the win! )
Next up is Jennifer Murdley's Toad by Bruce Coville (I'm really looking forward to this one, it's fantasy!), let's do this!


No comments:
Post a Comment